Other than the perfume "Angel" (I know, cheesy, but it smells so
good and I mean the Thierry Mugler scent, not the Victoria's Secret ick) all the the scents I wear come from Shawna at Slinky Minks. I've been buying from her for almost two years now. I know that BPAL has a massive number of scents and a lot of them are Kin-friendly, which makes them extremely cool, I have very sensitive skin and BPAL routinely made me itchy or break out in a rash.
My favorite scent by Shawna is Egyptian Musk, which is truly unisex and smells lovely - rich and spicy with musky undertones. I also love "6," whose name is taken from a reference to Anton LaVey's Synthesizer Clock. (She also sells 3, 9, and 12.) She has nowhere near the number of scents that BPAL does, but her line includes scented oil, sugar scrub, lip balm, shea butter, lotion, and a couple other things. Her turn around time is very fast, she uses as few (and as pure) ingredients in her scents as possible, and - YAY - her stuff doesn't make me itchy. Her prices are also outstanding.
So be sure to check out BPAL just for the sheer coolness of their website and their range of scents if nothing else. But if you have sensitive skin like me, or if you're just curious, try Shawna's line.
"Someday after we have mastered the winds, the waves, and gravity, we will harness for God the energies of love; and then for a second time in the history of the world, human beings will have discovered fire." - Teilhard de Chardin